Miu Miu Penny Loafer

Plus the ultimate round up of recommended loafers

Jennie Rogers

reached out with her review of her Miu Miu Penny Loafer right after I had made an investment in a pair of high-end loafers. It’s the largest investment I have made in a pair of shoes and, I have to admit, I don’t regret the purchase one bit. Spending more on leather goods (like shoes and bags) often yields higher quality pieces. Here’s Jennie’s notes on her loafer! And if it’s not the right time to invest in a pair of loafers, stick with us to the end where I round-up all the loafers recommended on SS below $600.

---

I discovered the incredible Miu Miu Penny Loafer on a trip to Italy a few months ago. After spotting it at the source - the Miu Miu store in Milan - I tried it on, I went away and thought about it. I tried it on again.

The shoe comes in various iterations so there was a lot to consider.

the many colorways and fabrications of the loafer

Ultimately though, I realized it was the ‘vintage effect’ loafer in white that stole my heart. So I took the plunge and bought it. I’m so glad I did.

Trying it on at Miu Miu. The shoe looks darker here than it actually is.

I’d actually been looking for a white loafer for a couple of years. There were lots of nice ones around but when I put them on they just looked….well, white. And somehow lacking in subtlety despite their neutral hue.

The unique detailing of this pair is what won me over. It has a worn look, which gives it a large dose of effortless appeal. Along with that, the shoe has a substantial slightly masculine silhouette. These qualities I think, are what sets it apart.

Vintage effect, vintage rug

Despite solid proportions though, it’s an extremely comfortable shoe. It moulds to your foot quickly and provides good support. Which explains why I often wear mine all day.

In fact I reach for this amazing shoe all the time. I like roomy clothes and it just seems to lighten the overall look and balance everything out.

Miu Mius with oversized blazer and wide leg jean.

But the versatility doesn’t stop there. It also looks great with slimmer pieces such as a straight leg jean or trouser. And I think it would look incredible with a midi skirt and ankle socks, although this is something I have yet to try.

The shoe has a rubber sole which provides good grip even in the wet, making it a perfect option almost year round. And It holds up extremely well, showing virtually no signs of wear. I guess the vintage effect has something to do with this.

There really isn’t anything negative I can say about this incredible shoe - aside from the fact that it’s very pricey ($1,170). Still, for all the reasons I’ve outlined I think it’s well worth the investment.

A final thing to note, sizing is slightly large. I’m a 38.5 to 39 and the 38.5 is perfect with a sock, but also without.

---

A huge thanks to

Jennie Rogers

for contributing her review, go check out her Substack here.

I took this opportunity to challenge myself to round up all the best of the recommended loafers from Substack’s chats with the caveat that they are under $600. I present to you my findings since loafers seem to be the definitive shoe of fall and we all need a pair. And may I note that all the most recommended loafers look strikingly similar! The Jamie Haller loafers are the most beloved among the Substack chats but sizing seems to vary wildly so maybe scroll the chats for tips if that is your favorite!

L to R: G.H. Bass ($175) // Sezane Albane ($230) // Sebago Dan ($250) // Anonymous Copenhagen Dico ($310) // Freda Salvador Elba ($375) // Jamie Haller ($595)

Thank you so much for reading and, please, submit your own review to onestarreviews.ss@gmail.com!